Showing posts with label Goshgarian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Goshgarian. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Taking Arendt at her word

In Sylvie Courtine-Denamy's Three Women in Dark Times we find this troubling quote:
The scholars first put to one side by the Nazis as of relatively little use to them were old-fashioned nationalists like Heidegger
G.M.Goshgarian may have meant "such as Heidegger" but the text bears a reference in footnote 88 of the English version to Arendt, "The Image of Hell".

Nothing in this matches Hugo Ott's documentation of the facts: but then again, Arendt was not there to know.

What is at issue is not an "image". In 1946, Arendt is speaking as a journalist.  Having been briefly in Gurs Camp, she may have believed that she understood what a Vernichtungslager was: but she did not.

The Goshgarian translation dates from 2000, Cornel University Press, long after it was known that Heidegger was no "old-fashioned nationalist" blabbing at a Bavarian Stammtisch and hankering for the days of Bismarck.